About the evaluation
As a main rule, the midway evaluation should include academic input from researchers within the candidate’s own field of study as well as from related disciplines. The primary purpose of the midway evaluation is to help the candidate identify factors that may put the project at risk of delay or stagnation, and to provide feedback that can enhance the quality of the work. The Faculty, the supervisor(s), and the candidate are all required to take an active role in addressing issues that may jeopardise the timely completion of the PhD training. This is to ensure, as far as possible, that the programme can be completed within the prescribed period of study.
- The department is responsible for convening the midway evaluation.
- The midway evaluation takes place when the candidate has completed approximately half of the doctoral research period.
- The evaluation is conducted in a meeting with the candidate, attended by representatives of the department’s leadership, academic staff, and administration.
- The academic representatives must include at least one member of staff in addition to the supervisor(s).
- The administrative representative is the department’s PhD coordinator or equivalent.
- Prior to the meeting, both the candidate and the principal supervisor must submit separate reports outlining the status of the thesis project.
- In addition, the candidate must submit a written text and give an oral presentation. The scope of the text and presentation is determined by the candidate’s academic environment.
Candidates submit a simplified progress report in the year in which the midway evaluation takes place.
Notice of the evaluation and documentation requirements
The department notifies candidates of the midway evaluation approximately six months in advance and sends a formal invitation to the candidate and the principal supervisor three weeks before the evaluation meeting is due to take place. The PhD candidate and the principal supervisor must each submit a written status report no later than one week before the meeting (maximum five pages). These reports must be submitted to the midway evaluation committee.
The reports should address:
- progress made in relation to the original project plan, including an assessment of the project’s development in light of that plan. Particular attention should be given to explaining any delays to the project;
- publications, conference participation, and similar academic activities (candidate only);
- the supervision provided up to the time of the evaluation, including the extent of supervision received, the main topics discussed, and an assessment of the supervision process;
- completed components of the training component prior to the evaluation (candidate only);
- an updated project plan, including proposed measures to address any delays in the project.
The evaluation committee
At departments, the committee consists of at least one representative of the department leadership (Head of Department or Research Coordinator), at least one academic staff member in addition to the principal supervisor, and the department’s administrative PhD coordinator or equivalent (secretary).
At centres, the committee consists of the Centre Director, one academic staff member appointed by the Centre Director (who is not one of the supervisors), and the Head of Administration (secretary).
If the Head of Department or the Centre Director is also serving as a supervisor, the Vice-Dean for Research appoints an alternative chair of the committee.
The midway evaluation meeting
The midway evaluation meeting is a one-hour meeting involving the PhD candidate, the main supervisor, and the mid-term evaluation committee. The discussion is based on the submitted reports, with the aim of facilitating a constructive dialogue about the project and its progress.
Both the candidate and the principal supervisor are offered the opportunity to meet privately with the committee.
Minutes must be taken using the designated template.
The minutes must state whether progress is considered satisfactory or unsatisfactory, and the conclusion must be justified. Any follow-up measures must be specified in detail, including responsibility for their implementation. The minutes must be signed by all participants and, together with the submitted reports, must be archived as confidential documents.
Follow-up of candidates whose progress is deemed unsatisfactory
The mid-term evaluation should result in a time-bound follow-up plan for candidates who are not making satisfactory progress.